Tagged: 

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Sondra Perl
    Keymaster
    Post count: 162

    I immediately related to the warped sense of reality that is a by-product of many adolescence lives. In the first chapters of Borkowski’s memoir, he propels the readers directly into the basis of his narrative with a powerful opening sentence, “The human body contains about seven liters of blood.” (1) The combination of leaking blood and the severity of it would make the most jaded person read on. Borkowski contributes a tremendous amount of personal material, creating a cast of characters and voices that help to navigate his terrain. The introduction of friends, family and a few neighborhood characters round out his circle of sustenance and influence. This type of memoir reminds me of the narrative arc of a “hero’s journey”.

    Borkowski uses time demarcations coupled with different voices to establish the context of the perspective we are observing. We hear from him as an established respectable adult and a blissfully ignorant youth. The mixture of boredom and obliviousness yields delusions that transport adolescence into adulthood. He states examples with the idea that cops are fake, “Everyone knew not to be afraid of the cops, who came out only at night. They were fake cops carrying fake weapons loaded with fake ammunition.” (2)

    That being said on close reading I found the some chapters to be a repetitive. Particularly the repetitive creed (paraphrasing here “it wasn’t a big deal, don’t think about it” from both parents. Perhaps by doing this he accomplishes the mirroring of his parental dictates and emphasizes to the reader how powerful and insidious their message was.

    For those who haven’t experienced an event(s) that absolutely and totally alter a person’s life, embed the event into their identity and revise their life’s trajectory, you must be aware that there is definitely a “BI” “before” the “incident” and “AI” an “after” the “incident”. Borkowski establishes this by the end of the first chapter. The imagery of Borkowski’s collapsed lung and the surgery that followed “like the surgery to repair my collapsed lung, which required doctors to cut me nearly in half, my life seems divided by that one incident.”(6) These two specific time references are intrinsically connected to memoir writing and imperative to establish right away.

    Anonymous
    Inactive
    Post count: 27

    Lindsey,
    This type of memoir reminds me of the narrative arc of a “hero’s journey” – I didn’t think of that at first, but it’s great, especially since I’m curious about his intentions behind us knowing immediately that he’s an English professor. Reading his text, I alternate between thinking he’s influenced by the academic essay style to the anecdotal style used on the streets to waste time. I think a certain mythic style is a cool reading of the text, too – only Borkowski attacks it from the middle, like the hamartia of the shooting is also his catharsis, revealing his fatal flaw but also saving his life.

    • This reply was modified 11 years, 5 months ago by .
    Website Services Admin
    Keymaster
    Post count: 31

    Lindsey and Megan,

    I’d be interested to know what you guys thought about some of the references to different literature. Did you feel it flowed well in the story, or did it feel forced? Did it feel forced because you knew he was an English professor?
    I did find some of the different tropes kind of repetitive – like the ‘this moment changed my life’ and the ‘my parents kept telling me to put it behind me’ but I did find that there was this contradiction he was building into the narrative that showed how his life didnt change immediately, or that his parents were constantly mentioning it.

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.